top of page

Why a tribunal quashed Maharashtra's 4 GWh battery storage tender

Writer: Vaultus
Vaultus
Jun 1
4 min read

Updated: 3 days ago

From our archive: we wrote this note after the week shown above, as part of our back catalogue. For anything newer, see the latest posts in this section.


On 5 June 2026 the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity set aside Maharashtra's 2,000 MW/4,000 MWh battery storage tender. Bidders had priced about 5,475 cycles over 15 years, but a condition added after bidding let the buyer call at least 6,300 at no extra cost. The lesson for any battery contract, large or small, is that the use a buyer can demand has to be fixed, priced and written down before signing.


The Storage Brief, week of 1 June 2026


What changed

On 5 June 2026 the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (APTEL) allowed appeals by several winning bidders against MERC's 6 March 2026 order, which had adopted the tariffs from MSEDCL's tender for 2,000 MW/4,000 MWh of battery storage for 15 years, Energetica India reported.


The issue was a Ministry of Power letter of 31 December 2025. It let MSEDCL run the batteries at one cycle a day, but only if MSEDCL kept a contractual right to use them for at least 6,300 cycles at no extra cost. That condition is part of the central viability gap support rules for standalone batteries, revised in 2025.


APTEL called the change "changing the rules of the game" after bids. It set aside the tariff order, quashed the bidding and cancelled the letters of intent. MSEDCL must return the bidders' security deposits within four weeks.


Why it matters

A battery wears out as it's used, and use is counted in cycles: one full charge and discharge. A clause that lets the buyer call more cycles than the seller priced hands the buyer a free option. The seller carries the cost of replacing cells sooner, and nobody has paid for it. The tribunal saw exactly that: MSEDCL could use the right at any time, creating obligations the bidders hadn't priced. MSEDCL also offered to compensate bidders if the central support was denied, but that offer lacked the regulator's approval and wasn't treated as enforceable.


The same logic applies to a ₹2 crore battery at a hospital. Example: say the hospital's monthly plan is priced for one cycle a day over seven years, and the site starts cycling twice a day to cover both evening peaks and outages. Our calculation: one cycle a day is 2,555 cycles over seven years (365 × 7), while two a day is 5,110 (730 × 7). If the contract is silent on use, the maker carries that extra wear, and so does whoever lends against the payments. A clear cycle clause decides whether the payment stream survives a dispute.


What it means for you

  • Sites: Ask what your battery contract assumes about daily use, and what it costs if you need more. A clear limit protects you as much as the maker.

  • Battery makers: Price the cycles the contract allows, not the cycles in the brochure. Make sure your cell warranty covers the use your customer can actually call.

  • Lenders: Read the cycle clause and any condition tied to central or state support before approving credit. Ask whether any promise in the contract needs a regulator's approval to be enforceable.


The number

825 extra cycles: the gap between what bidders priced and what the buyer could call, about 15% more use than priced. Source: our calculation, 6,300 − 5,475 = 825 and 825 ÷ 5,475 ≈ 15%, where 5,475 is one cycle a day for 15 years (365 × 15).


What to do now

  1. Pull every battery contract or quote you hold and find the clause on daily cycles or energy throughput.

  2. Check that the cell supplier's warranty matches that clause in cycles and years.

  3. If any term depends on a subsidy or support scheme, write down what happens to the price if that support doesn't arrive.


What we don't know yet

  • Whether MSEDCL or MERC will challenge the judgment further.

  • When MSEDCL will tender again, and on what cycle terms.

  • Whether other states running tenders under the same support conditions face similar disputes.


Questions we get asked

Q: What is a battery cycle and why does it matter in a contract? A: One full charge and one full discharge. Battery wear, and most cell warranties, are counted in cycles as well as years.


Q: Does the APTEL judgment on the MSEDCL tender affect business battery contracts? A: Not directly. It concerns one state utility's tender. The principle it applies, that a contract can't be changed after it's priced, is worth building into any battery agreement.


Key facts

  • Document: APTEL judgment setting aside MERC's tariff adoption for MSEDCL's 2,000 MW/4,000 MWh BESS tender, as reported by Energetica India

  • Issued by: Appellate Tribunal for Electricity (APTEL)

  • Date: 5 June 2026

  • Status: in force (tariff order set aside, bidding quashed, letters of intent cancelled)

  • Applies to: MSEDCL's 15-year battery storage tender adopted by MERC on 6 March 2026

  • Takes effect: 5 June 2026; security deposits to be returned within four weeks

  • What it means for business batteries: the number of cycles a buyer can call has to be fixed and priced before signing.


Sources


Keep reading





Vaultus puts business batteries on a monthly plan. The battery maker installs and maintains the system, the site pays monthly, and the contract sets how much backup it gets. Send your last 12 months of electricity bills and diesel records to contact@vaultus.io, or run your own numbers with the site calculator.

bottom of page