top of page

Battery or generator: the daily-running test

Writer: Vaultus
Vaultus
Oct 30
7 min read

Updated: 10 hours ago

Updated 17 November 2026: we rebuilt the test around litres of diesel replaced a year, added a check you can run from your own invoices and logbook, a list of questions for your supplier, common mistakes, and current Uttar Pradesh and Delhi time-of-day rates.


A battery beats a diesel generator only when the diesel it stops you buying each year is worth more than the battery costs each year. Hours on the logbook matter only because they turn into litres, and the same three hours a day can mean 15,000 litres a year at one site and 32,000 at another. If your site runs its generator rarely, keep the generator: a battery will not pay for itself on diesel.


The Storage Brief, guide, updated 17 November 2026


Key dates

  • 30 Oct 2026 (in force): Diesel at ₹95.20 a litre in Delhi, unchanged through October. Source

  • 21 Oct 2026 (reported): GRAP Stage I invoked across Delhi-NCR. Diesel sets must not be a regular power source. Source

  • 2 Jul 2026: date of Uttar Pradesh's 2026-27 tariff order, with time-of-day rates for large industry. Source


Why hours alone mislead

Take two sites that each log three hours of generator running a day (an example).


  • Site A carries 100 kW during cuts and gets 3.4 units a litre. It burns about 32,206 litres a year, or ₹30.7 lakh at ₹95.20 (our calculation: 100 × 3 × 365 ÷ 3.4).

  • Site B carries 40 kW on a lightly loaded set and gets 2.8 units a litre. It burns about 15,643 litres a year, or ₹14.9 lakh (our calculation: 40 × 3 × 365 ÷ 2.8).


Same hours, half the diesel. Three things separate them: the load the set carries, how many units it makes per litre, and how much of the running falls in cuts short enough for a battery to carry.


The test, from your own papers

You need four documents: 12 months of diesel invoices, the generator logbook, one electricity bill and one battery quote.


  1. Litres burnt (L). Litres invoiced in 12 months, less any rise in tank stock.

  2. Units per litre (u). Units on the set's meter over the same period, divided by L. The Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE) monitoring table shows 2.76 to 3.45 units a litre (our calculation: 1 ÷ 0.362 and 1 ÷ 0.290 litres per unit). Every set in that table ran at 65% or more of its derated capacity. A backup set at light load will usually do worse, so use your own figure.

  3. Share the battery can reach (S). Split the logbook by cut length. Hours in cuts shorter than the battery's run time count in full. In longer cuts, only the first part counts, because the generator takes over.

  4. Net saving per litre. Diesel price minus the grid power needed to replace that litre: price − (u × grid rate ÷ round-trip efficiency). Round-trip efficiency is the share of energy you get back out of the battery.

  5. Annual battery cost (C). The monthly charge × 12, or the yearly cost of buying it outright.


Litres the battery would replace = L × S. If that number, times the net saving per litre, is above C, diesel savings alone pay for the battery. The break-even is C ÷ net saving per litre.


A worked example

A Delhi-NCR factory has critical loads of 100 kW during cuts (an example). A supplier quotes a 300 kWh battery, enough for three hours at that load, at ₹1,00,000 a month including maintenance, or ₹12 lakh a year (an example, not a quote; use your own). Grid power costs ₹9 a unit and the quote states 85% round trip (both an example).


  • Grid power per litre replaced: at 3 units a litre, ₹31.76 (our calculation: 3 × 9 ÷ 0.85).

  • Net saving per litre: ₹63.44 (our calculation: 95.20 − 31.76).

  • Break-even: about 18,917 litres a year that the battery can reach, about ₹18 lakh of diesel (our calculation: 12,00,000 ÷ 63.44; 18,917 × 95.20).

  • In hours: at 100 kW the set burns 33.3 litres an hour, so 18,917 litres is about 568 hours a year, or 1.6 hours a day (our calculation: 18,917 × 3 ÷ 100).

  • Battery use: 568 hours at 100 kW is about 56,800 units a year, around 189 full cycles of 300 kWh (our calculation: 568 × 100; ÷ 300). Check that the warranty allows that many.


Two changes move the bar.


  • A more efficient set raises it. At 3.5 units a litre, each litre needs more grid power to replace. Net saving falls to ₹58.14 and the break-even rises to about 20,639 litres (our calculation: 95.20 − 3.5 × 9 ÷ 0.85 = 58.14; 12,00,000 ÷ 58.14).

  • A less efficient battery raises it too. The Central Electricity Authority's 2026 technical standards set a round-trip floor of at least 70% for the battery systems they cover, Power Line reported. At 70% and 3 units a litre, the break-even is about 21,191 litres (our calculation: 12,00,000 ÷ (95.20 − 3 × 9 ÷ 0.7)).


Can the bill make up a shortfall?

Rarely by much in Delhi-NCR. Between cuts, a battery can shift units from expensive to cheap hours. The gaps are narrow once losses are counted.


  • Uttar Pradesh. Large industry (HV-2) at 11 kV pays ₹7.10 a kVAh. In winter, 5pm to 11pm costs 15% more and 11pm to 5am 15% less. In summer the peak runs 7pm to 3am and the cheap window 5am to 10am. Shifting one unit earns about ₹1.07 after 85% round trip (our calculation: 7.10 × 1.15 − 7.10 × 0.85 ÷ 0.85). Shifting 150 units a day earns about ₹58,300 a year (our calculation: 150 × 365 × 1.065).

  • Delhi. DERC's FY 2019-20 tariff schedule set a 20% peak surcharge and a 20% off-peak rebate for May to September only. On its industrial rate of ₹7.75 a kVAh, that is about ₹2 a unit for five months (our calculation: 7.75 × 1.2 = 9.30; 7.75 × 0.8 = 6.20; 9.30 − 6.20 ÷ 0.85). Delhi's prevailing tariff order is dated 30 September 2021, DERC said in August 2026, so check the current rate on your bill.

  • Haryana. HERC found the existing time-of-day tariff ineffective and asked DISCOMs for a fresh proposal, The Tribune reported.


Set against ₹12 lakh a year, these are small. Bill savings also compete with backup: energy used for shifting is not there for a cut. See the seven bill lines for the full picture.


When the generator still wins

  • Rare cuts. At 20 hours of cuts a year, the factory above burns about 667 litres, or ₹63,467 (our calculation: 100 kW × 20 hours ÷ 3 units × ₹95.20). That is less than one month's battery charge in the example. Keep the generator.

  • Very long cuts. The 300 kWh battery lasts three hours at 100 kW. An eight-hour cut needs 800 kWh plus a margin (our calculation: 100 kW × 8 hours). For most sites the answer is a battery and generator hybrid.

  • No recharge window. Back-to-back cuts leave the battery no time to refill.


Common mistakes

  • Using hours without load. Litres are what you pay for. Hours × kW ÷ units per litre turns one into the other.

  • Using the brochure figure for units per litre. Use meter units over invoiced litres. A lightly loaded set often makes far fewer.

  • Counting hours the battery cannot reach. The fifth hour of a five-hour cut stays on diesel unless you buy five hours of battery.

  • Counting generator upkeep savings while keeping the generator. If the set stays, its annual service contract mostly stays too. Count only the running costs that fall.

  • Leaving out recharge cost and losses. Every litre replaced needs grid units to replace it.

  • Using the pump price when you buy in bulk. Use your invoice price.


What to ask your supplier

  • What is the usable kWh at the start, and in the final year of the contract?

  • What round-trip efficiency, measured from AC in to AC out including cooling and other auxiliary loads?

  • How many cycles a year does the warranty allow, and what happens if we use more?

  • Who fixes the battery, how fast, and who pays if it stops working?

  • How much energy is held back for cuts if the battery also shifts units for the bill?

  • What does the price cover, and can it change during the contract?


Questions people ask

Q: Rerun the payback with our actual generator hours. What else do you need? A: The load the set carries during cuts, litres invoiced over the same months, and how long each cut lasted. Hours only become rupees through those three.


Q: How many litres of diesel a year make a battery worth it? A: In our example, about 19,000 to 21,000 litres a year that the battery can reach (18,917 at 3 units a litre and 85% round trip, 21,191 at 70%). Your figure is your annual battery cost divided by your net saving per litre.


Q: Finance asked for the full amount upfront. How do we compare that with diesel? A: Turn the price into a yearly cost and run the same test. ₹75 lakh repaid over 10 years at 10% is about ₹12.2 lakh a year before upkeep (an example; our calculation: 75,00,000 × 0.1 ÷ (1 − 1.1^−10)). At ₹63.44 net a litre, that needs about 19,242 litres a year. Add upkeep, insurance and repairs before you compare it with a monthly charge that already includes maintenance.


Sources


Keep reading


Vaultus puts business batteries on a monthly plan. The battery maker installs and maintains the system, the site pays monthly, and the contract sets how much backup it gets. Send your last 12 months of electricity bills and diesel records to contact@vaultus.io, or run your own numbers with the site calculator.

bottom of page