The demand trap: why cutting contract demand can backfire

Updated: 3 days ago
From our archive: we wrote this note after the week shown above, as part of our back catalogue. For anything newer, see the latest posts in this section.
Cutting contract demand lowers the minimum demand charge you pay each month. It only pays if your peaks stay under the new figure. Go over it and most states bill the excess at a penalty rate. Telangana can reprice the whole month's energy, and in Maharashtra one high month can raise your billed demand for the next eleven. Hold the peak below a target first, with a battery or load control. Cut contract demand once the meter shows you can.
The Storage Brief, guide, updated 1 November 2026
Key dates
1 Apr 2026 (in force): Gujarat tariff schedule: an 85% billing floor and ₹555 per excess kVA. Source
1 Apr 2026 (in force): Telangana 2026-27 schedule: penalties for demand above contract demand. Source
26 May 2021 (in force): MERC's practice direction quotes Regulation 7.6 on resetting contract demand after three excess months. Source
7 Jul 2017 (in force): Delhi's Supply Code, Regulation 17: limits on load cuts and a yearly revision from 1 July. Source
How contract demand sets your bill
Contract demand is the kVA (kilovolt-ampere, the unit of demand) you agree with your DISCOM. Most tariffs bill demand on the higher of your recorded peak and a fixed share of contract demand. So contract demand sets a floor.
Gujarat: billing demand is the highest of the month's actual maximum demand, 85% of contract demand, or 100 kVA (GERC tariff schedule, clause 11.4).
Maharashtra: MSEDCL's HT bill format for December 2025 takes the highest of recorded demand, 75% of the highest demand in the preceding 11 months, and 75% of contract demand (MSEDCL bill).
West Bengal: WBSEDCL's 2025-26 tariff bills demand "on the basis of recorded demand", naming no floor (WBSEDCL tariff gist). We could not check the tariff regulation it cites.
A site with modest peaks pays for kVA it never uses. So cutting looks attractive.
What happens when you go over
Gujarat: kVA above contract demand are billed at ₹555 each a month, against ₹150 to ₹475 within it (clauses 11.1.1 and 11.1.2).
Telangana: if recorded demand is 100% to 120% of contract demand, the excess kVA pay twice the normal demand charge. Above 120%, all the month's energy is also billed at 1.15 times, and above 200% at 1.20 times (TGSPDCL schedule 2026-27, clause 5). For an 11 kV HT-II(A) site using 2,00,000 units (an example) at ₹8.80, crossing 120% once adds ₹2,64,000 to that month's energy charge (our calculation: 0.15 × ₹8.80 × 2,00,000).
Maharashtra: if a consumer exceeds contract demand three times in a financial year and does not regularise, the DISCOM "shall revise its Contract Demand to the highest recorded Maximum Demand in that Financial Year" (Regulation 7.6 of MERC's 2021 Supply Code, quoted in MERC's practice direction of 26 May 2021).
The look-back rule
A look-back rule (a ratchet) makes today's bill depend on an earlier peak. Maharashtra bills on one. We found none in the Gujarat, Telangana or West Bengal tariff schedules or Delhi's supply code, though we did not read each full tariff order. MSEDCL's December 2025 bill format includes 75% of the highest demand in the preceding 11 months. Its December 2024 reply in its tariff case quotes the same rule from MERC's order in Case 226 of 2022, "subject to the limit of Contract Demand" (MSEDCL reply).
So one 900 kVA month (an example) sets a floor of 675 kVA for the next eleven bills, if contract demand is at least that high (our calculation: 0.75 × 900). We could not open the 2025-26 tariff order, so check the current wording with MSEDCL.
Delhi uses a look-back for contract demand itself, not the bill. Under Regulation 17(4) of DERC's 2017 Supply Code, the DISCOM revises contract demand each year from 1 July. It uses the highest average of maximum demand over any four consecutive months of the preceding financial year (DERC Supply Code).
How and when you can cut
Delhi: a load reduction request is accepted "only after six months from original energisation for connections up to 100 KW, and 1 (one) year" for connections above 100 kW. Later requests are accepted once in six months, and the cut is "limited to the highest of average of any 4 (four) consecutive months maximum demand readings of last 12 (twelve) months" (Regulation 17(3)). Amendments followed in 2018 and 2019, so read the current text.
Maharashtra: the DISCOM revises contract demand on application (Regulation 7.6). MERC noted in 2021 that it is "being so practiced that Contract Demand can be changed once in a Billing Cycle", and let HT sites change it twice a cycle until 31 March 2022.
A worked example
Take a Gujarat factory on HTP-I with 1,000 kVA of contract demand (an example). Its normal monthly peak is 650 kVA, but in 8 months of the year a short spike reaches 850 kVA. On our reading of clause 11.1, kVA up to contract demand pay the slab rates and the excess pays ₹555.
Keep 1,000 kVA: billing demand is 850 kVA every month (the 85% floor). Our calculation: 500 × ₹150 + 350 × ₹260 = ₹1,66,000 a month, or ₹19,92,000 a year.
Cut to 700 kVA, no peak control: normal months bill 650 kVA: 500 × ₹150 + 150 × ₹260 = ₹1,14,000. Spike months: 500 × ₹150 + 200 × ₹260 + 150 × ₹555 = ₹2,10,250. Year: 4 × ₹1,14,000 + 8 × ₹2,10,250 = ₹21,38,000, which is ₹1,46,000 more than not cutting (our calculation).
Cut to 700 kVA, battery holds 680 kVA: spike months bill 680 kVA: 500 × ₹150 + 180 × ₹260 = ₹1,21,800. Year: 4 × ₹1,14,000 + 8 × ₹1,21,800 = ₹14,30,400, or ₹5,61,600 less than keeping 1,000 kVA (our calculation).
The break-even is close. Here, cutting without control costs more once spikes hit 7 or more months a year (our calculation: a spike month costs ₹44,250 more than today, a normal month saves ₹52,000, and 44,250n > 52,000(12 − n) when n > 6.48).
How a battery makes the cut safe
A battery discharges when demand nears a target, say 680 kVA against a 700 kVA contract. The meter never records the spike. Three things decide whether that holds:
Size: enough power for the gap between spike and target, and enough energy to last the spike.
Charge: its control must keep a reserve for the spike.
Contract: it should name the target kVA and what happens in a month it is missed.
What to do this week
List contract demand, recorded demand and billing demand from your last 12 bills.
Ask your DISCOM for 15-minute load profiles and count the months with a spike above your target.
Before you apply, read your state's supply code clause on cutting contract demand, including any lock-in.
Questions people ask
Q: Should I reduce my contract demand to lower my electricity bill? A: Only if your peaks reliably stay below the new figure. Otherwise penalty rates on the excess can wipe out the saving.
Q: How often can I change my contract demand? A: In Delhi, once in six months after the first year for connections above 100 kW. In Maharashtra, MERC described the practice in 2021 as once a billing cycle. Check the current rule with MSEDCL.
Sources
Tariff schedule for DGVCL, MGVCL, PGVCL and UGVCL, w.e.f. 1 April 2026. Gujarat Electricity Regulatory Commission, March 2026.
Retail supply tariff schedule, 1 April 2026 to 31 March 2027. TGSPDCL, 2026.
Practice direction: revision of contract demand in a billing cycle. Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission, 26 May 2021.
DERC (Supply Code and Performance Standards) Regulations, 2017, and amendments. Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission, 7 July 2017.
HT bill of supply, December 2025. MSEDCL, January 2026.
Reply to MYT queries, set 2. MSEDCL, 24 December 2024.
Gist of tariff order 2025-26. WBSEDCL, March 2025.
Keep reading
Next guide: Battery or generator: the daily-running test
Where tariffs are heading: Business power tariffs in 2026-27: which way are they moving?
Check your site: Which battery and diesel rules apply to my site? A quick check for India
Vaultus puts business batteries on a monthly plan. The battery maker installs and maintains the system, the site pays monthly, and the contract sets how much backup it gets. Send your last 12 months of electricity bills and diesel records to contact@vaultus.io, or run your own numbers with the site calculator.
